lady_*nix wrote:Sigma - first off, you don't know shit about the US left, no offense. I know your own country is a horror show right now, and has been for a while, and I'm sorry about that, but that doesn't make you magically know everything about the US' political catastrophes - not even given US politics' repercussions on Venezuela. And yes, this is a thing I run into a lot from people outside the US.
Second, for the millionth time, I'm not telling people not to vote. I'm not telling people to vote red. That's fucking stupid. Stop putting words in my mouth. I'm telling people that voting alone isn't enough. We vote Dem because we have no fucking choice, that's not going to change. But we also have to exert pressure on the system through non-electoral means: strikes, protests, building underground power, sabotage. It's not enough to vote in people who maybe hopefully just possibly won't throw us to the wolves, and depend on them saving us (like, you know, a messiah).
Third, there's a lot more going on than just idiots not voting. See: gerrymandering, an electoral and govt system designed to give land votes instead of people, regulatory capture, vast corporate propaganda organs. Voter suppression, which I've mentioned like a dozen times and you still refuse to accept is as bad as it truly is. A history of racism and slavery, esp. in the South but also everywhere, and a particular hierarchy coming out of that history that conservatives wish to bring back. (And no I'm not saying similar doesn't exist in Latin America, I know y'all used to have plantations too.) A culture of extreme individualism. Police forces that are utterly unaccountable, and pretty much outside government control. Absolutely staggering wealth inequality. Gerontocracy. Every single one of these feeds back into itself in a vicious circle.
Sorry to be, like, all rage but I'm kind of sick and fucking tired of seeing you (and other people here) insult my intelligence like this, and deliberately misunderstand what I'm saying. Telling people to not vote wouldn't just be stupid for me, it would be suicidal, and I'm really not in the mood to explain this shit but here we are.
First of all LN. I am sorry. I didn't mean to insult you.
Second. When I said "You" I didn't mean YOU PERSONALLY. I meant the US in general. As in "YOU GRINGOS".
When you say that I don't know jack about the left in the US. I am pretty sure you are right. I don't live there. I don't see how "Joe/Jane Average" deal with the current situation in your country. HOWEVER THIS IS NOT A "RIGHT OR LEFT" thing. It's an "AUTHORITARIANISM vs everything else" thing. But, since you brought up the point, allow me to clarify. I DON'T HAVE a virulent hatred for the Left. I think that centrally planned economies don't work. And so far I see no evidence that they ever did. So, I don't trust people who still propose that. But I don't hate them. Do you know who I really hate? All those useful idiots from first world countries that even these days pretend to give any form of support to a fourth rate dictator like Nicolás Maduro. Those worthless pieces of refuse spout all those lofty ideals you favor (and no I am not blaming you for favoring them), and in the same breath they say whatever they can to provide cover for a lowlife like Maduro. Remember all those people I said that drove my pressure up on another thread? Do you know what they have in common? It's not that they are all left wingers. It's that every single one of them is an unrepentant Maduro apologist. So, having clarified that, let's continue.
As I said in the paragraph above this is not a "Left vs Right" thing. It's an "Authoritarians vs everybody else" thing. I won't discuss that I don't know about the left in the US. HOWEVER, at the risk of sounding condescending. I think that I am better qualified than anyone else in this board to talk about authoritarians. Why? Because MY CULTURE IS AUTHORITARIAN. That has been the bane of Latin America since the 19th century.
First of all: Authoritarianism has NO IDEOLOGY. Or more accurately: it will adopt whatever ideology that allows it to reach and keep its hold on power. So: despite that Fascist are extreme right wing., The Left has plenty of authoritarians as well. While there have been plenty of examples of that (The USSR, China, North Korea, Cuba) there are other more subtle examples. Here in the region we've had several dictatorships that were left wing. DESPITE THAT THEY WERE NOT COMMUNISTS.
Second: And this is VERY important. THESE DAYS most Authoritarians get to power through elections. And very often with widespread popular support. Hugo Chavez was an example of that. His coup attempt failed miserably. But managed to get himself elected. And was popular enough to stay in power until he died. I made the mistake of expecting Chavistas to bow out when the economy went to hell. Look how well that worked.
Now, regarding abstention-ism: I know pretty well that you have an imperative to hold your nose and vote for the Dems. And I am pretty sure that most everyone you know is probably in the same position. Just remember one thing: There are over 250 Million people in the US that are allowed to vote. So, my point remains the same: Considering what was at stake in the 2020 election, the fact that only 66% of you gringos bothered to vote (and the fact that that was hailed as a "Record Turnout") is unacceptable. And according to every source I've read, abstention-ism is much worse in midterm elections. And even worse in elections at the local and state level. So it IS a big factor. Particularly because all those authoritarians that love Trump sure went in to vote. And again, I didn't just blame "The Left" in the US, AFAIK Independents fail to show up to the ballot box as well.
Regarding gerrymandering: I know exactly what it is. And that is has been a major issue in US Politics since at least 2010. I am certainly not an expert in US politics. But I follow it quite closely. For the simple reason that for better or worse, internal US politics have repercussions all over the world. Yet, gerrymandering did not stop the Dems from getting house majorities in the US Congress in 2018 and 2020 (even if they lost several seats in 2020) did it? And AFAIK, gerrymandering doesn't work with US Senate seats. It does work in state legislatures though. But, just like in the last few years several GOP gerrymandering districts have been forcefully redrawn by the courts, there is the possibility of doing the same at the state level. And yet how did those nutjobs at the state legislatures got elected in the first place? I'd bet good money that it was because of abstention-ism.
Voting restrictions OTOH, are much more effective. I should know, I saw them in action in several of the sham elections that Maduro has held since 2016. Yet those can be overcome if enough voters show up. I realize that showing up to vote can be pretty hard in the US. Since election day is usually on a weekday, which is pretty onerous on people who work for a living (particularly those who live from hand to mouth) But, in the end, as callous as it may sound it boils down to how high the stakes are. And, as you know better than I, the stakes are PARTICULARLY high this time. Not only for you, not only for the people you care about. But for your whole country. And even for the rest of the world.
Now, regarding "Non-electoral means": Strikes? There MIGHT be a chance since there seems to be a feeble revival of organized labor in the US. But, My own experience with it has been quite negative. We had a national strike in 2002-2003 to unseat Chavez. It achieved even less than nothing. The strike and the economic upheaval it caused gave the government to perfect excuse to impose stiffs foreign exchange controls which gave it ABSOLUTE control of the economy. And it left the opposition in pretty bad shape. (At this point I'd like to point out for UMPTEENTH time that the ideology of the groups that we call "Opposition" here in Venezuela is ALSO left wing. Despite what the foreign chavista apologists say).
Protests? Over 20 years of protests achieved exactly zilch here and don't get me started with civil disobedience. In 2014 plenty of students held major sit-ins And all they got for their troubles was being thrown in jail. IIRC there were plenty of protests in the US after Trump was elected. IIRC those protests didn't achieve much. And, BTW the objective of things like that is to influence public opinion, right? And just how that public opinion exerts its power? Through the ballot box doesn't it? So we are back where we started aren't we? So: Sorry if I sound flippant, but: Good luck with that.
Building underground power? Sabotage?, I am not sure what you mean with that. However I'd like to remind you what happened with those protests that went out of hand in Seattle and Portland. It quickly became fodder for the GOP. To the point that for months, every time they were questioned about the attempted coup in Jan 6 they'd try to say "what about ANTIFA"? Situations like that are goldmines for authoritarians. Gives them perfect excuses to impose restrictions like MTG's "Marshall Law" (sic).
Despite that I am quite sure that this doesn't need any explaining. I'd like to add I think that boycotting elections won't work either. Doing that, was certainly the final nail in the coffin where my country lies in.
You can call me hypocritical if you like. I stopped voting in 2017 because it became more than obvious that Maduro is rigging elections. Call me the guy that gave up if you like. My point remains the same: Your country hasn't reached that level of authoritarianism YET. But, if the GOP nutjobs take over the US Congress in November, I would not be surprised if you people reached that level of authoritarianism in the middle or even in the short term.